AI

help edit space_dashboard
Draft — This content has not been approved for publication.

AI-authored proposal child for the Published parent Hyperon AI Algorithms+MetaMo (Motivational Framework) (ID 795). Created as part of the Non-clustered Hyperon AI Algorithms cluster pilot Source 2 (MetaMo) close, 2026-05-06. Apply, revise, or reject at human reviewer's discretion. Cluster-pilot extraction archive: scripts/archive/non_clustered_haa_pilot/source2_metamo_paper/ with three-way Codex+Gemini+orchestrator sign-off on findings_reconciled_crossmodel.txt.

Summary of proposed corrections

The cluster-pilot reconciliation locked seven V2-X carry-forwards. Two of them are still unfixed in the current Sandra-spec sibling cards as of this proposal's creation (the Sandra-spec port at 18:22-18:33Z today renamed the parent and split content into per-field siblings, but did not update the substantive content of those siblings). The two unfixed items:

  1. V2-1 [METAMO-AUTHORSHIP-ORDER-WIKI-DRIFT] — the +responsible sibling card (ID 7566) currently reads "Ruiting Lian, Ben Goertzel". Both AGI 2025 papers list "Ben Goertzel and Ruiting Lian" on p.1 — Goertzel first, Lian second. The wiki ordering is reversed.
  2. V2-2 / V2-3 / V2-4 — the +github sibling card (ID 7567) currently lists only iCog-Labs-Dev/hyperon-openpsi as the MetaMo implementation. Per the cluster-pilot reconciliation this is the OpenPsi predecessor substrate, not the primary MetaMo implementation at HEAD. The trilateral classification (formal-reference + heuristic-prototype + predecessor-substrate) belongs in this card.

Two adjacent items were resolved at the substantive content layer in this same close batch and need no proposal:

  • V2-7 [MAGUS-BOUNDARY-EXTERNAL-COMPONENT] — added to Historical Lineage as a new section attributing MAGUS to Mikeda 2024.
  • Substantive trilateral framing — added to Status and Resources as a four-row implementation-anchors table.

Proposal P-AI-1: Correct +responsible authorship ordering

Target card: Hyperon AI Algorithms+MetaMo (Motivational Framework)+responsible (PlainText, ID 7566)

Current content:

Ruiting Lian, Ben Goertzel

Proposed content:

Ben Goertzel, Ruiting Lian

Rationale: Direct reading of publication_texts/mattermost_papers/AGI_25_METAMO_One.json p.1 + MetaMo_Two.json p.1 confirms "Ben Goertzel and Ruiting Lian" on both 2025 AGI papers. Goertzel-first ordering is also consistent with the corresponding Publications stub cards in this wiki. The double-blind-review pseudonym placeholders ("T.S. Peeps", "N. Body") in paper-2's reference list are not actual authors and should not influence the +responsible field.

Proposal P-AI-2: Replace +github with trilateral repo split

Target card: Hyperon AI Algorithms+MetaMo (Motivational Framework)+github (RichText, ID 7567)

Current content:

<ul><li>https://github.com/iCog-Labs-Dev/hyperon-openpsi</li></ul>

Proposed content:

<ul>
<li>https://github.com/iCog-Labs-Dev/MetaMo-Python — primary formal reference (Python; categorical skeleton: AppraisalComonad + DecisionMonad + MetaMoPseudoBimonad)</li>
<li>https://github.com/glicerico/MetaMo-Prototype — heuristic prototype (Python LangGraph/LLM rewrite; no formal categorical structure)</li>
<li>https://github.com/iCog-Labs-Dev/hyperon-openpsi — predecessor OpenPsi substrate (MeTTa; zero MetaMo/MAGUS naming at HEAD; the operational substrate the appraisal comonad abstracts)</li>
<li>https://github.com/iCog-Labs-Dev/PeTTa-OpenPSI — Prolog-port variant of OpenPsi substrate</li>
</ul>

Rationale:

  • V2-2 [METAMO-PYTHON-PRIMARY-REFERENCE]: iCog-Labs-Dev/MetaMo-Python at HEAD 3ec409b is the categorical reference implementation. (WebFetch verified 2026-05-06: HTTP 200; ~33 commits; primary committer Nahom Senay; README "A Python implementation of MetaMo, a category theory-based motivational framework for open-ended AGI systems".)
  • V2-4 [METAMO-PROTOTYPE-HEURISTIC-PARALLEL-PROTOTYPE]: glicerico/MetaMo-Prototype is a heuristic LangGraph/LLM rewrite, separate paradigm. (WebFetch verified 2026-05-06: HTTP 200; ~24 commits; forked from dagemawinegash/MetaMo-Prototype; primary committer Dagemawi Bekele.)
  • V2-3 [HYPERON-OPENPSI-PREDECESSOR-NOT-METAMO-IMPL]: iCog-Labs-Dev/hyperon-openpsi at HEAD 3b356c5 is the OpenPsi predecessor — targeted searches for "MetaMo" / "MAGUS" / "individuation" / "transcendence" return zero matches. (WebFetch verified 2026-05-06: HTTP 200; ~575 commits; "MeTTa experiments for the OpenPsi Architecture".)
  • PeTTa-OpenPsi is preserved as a fourth entry because the wiki's pre-Sandra-spec content already listed it as a Prolog-port variant; the cluster-pilot reconciliation did not specifically extract it but the Status and Resources subcard's existing content treats it as an operational variant of the OpenPsi substrate.

Notes for the human reviewer

  • Both proposals (P-AI-1, P-AI-2) are independently applicable; no ordering dependency.
  • The Sandra-spec port pattern (per memory/reference_wiki_content_subcard_convention.md) reserves +github as a list-of-URLs RichText sibling. The trilateral split above preserves that structure; the prose role-tags fit within <li> elements as the existing card does.
  • If the reviewer prefers a more compact +github (URL-only, no role tags) and wants the trilateral framing kept exclusively in Status and Resources, the alternative minimal P-AI-2 is just the four URLs without inline role descriptions — both representations are paper-faithful.
  • WebFetch verification per memory/feedback_webfetch_verify_external_urls.md was performed pre-write on all three primary URLs (MetaMo-Python, MetaMo-Prototype, hyperon-openpsi); all returned HTTP 200 and active development on 2026-05-06. PeTTa-OpenPsi URL was NOT freshly verified in this proposal's pre-write window since it carried over from existing wiki content; reviewer may verify before applying P-AI-2 if desired.